Successful projects deliver their scope with quality within the agreed upon time and cost. Integrated Monitoring and Controlling of schedule, scope, cost, risks, resources and quality throughout the project’s life cycle starting from project planning till the asset transition is mandatory for project success. While most of the leading project management frameworks like PMBOK by the Project Management Institute (PMI), PRINCE2 by Axelos, TCM framework by AACE, LEAN and Agile support this, each one of them have their strengths. While some are well suited for traditional projects with longer milestones (EPC), others fit well for projects which calls for inter-disciplinary team work within shorter milestones (R&D, Early phases of EPC, Snagging etc).

Though this kind of segmentation of projects based on frequency of milestones and interdisciplinary coordination is effective from the academic perspective, in reality all EPC projects have phases of shorter and longer milestones with varying degree of inter disciplinary coordination needs. Hence by sticking to any one particular framework while defining the Integrated Project Monitoring and Control strategy will result in sub-optimal monitoring and control. With this as the case, we at Wrench Academy conducted substantial research cutting across the leading project management frameworks to provide the best of the best practices approach to Integrated Project Monitoring and Control (IPMC).

Overview of the leading frameworks

Project Management Body Of Knowledge (PMBOK)

PMBOK by the Project Management Institute (USA) is the most popular among the project management frameworks. It comprises of 49 processes grouped into 10 knowledge areas of;

• Project integration management
• Scope management
• Schedule management Cost management
• Quality management
• Resource management
• Communications management
• Risk management
• Procurement management
• Stakeholder management

The coverage of this framework is excellent as it covers most of the aspects of professional project management.

Projects in Controlled Environment (PRINCE2)

PRINCE2 is the British standard for project management maintained by Axelos. PRINCE2 is a structured process-based approach to project management. The processes comprise of;

• Starting up a project
• Directing a project
• Initiating a project
• Managing stage boundaries
• Planning

While there are lot of commonalities between PMBOK and PRINCE2, PRINCE2 is highly prescriptive in nature when compared to PMBOK.

Total Cost Management (TCM)

The Total Cost Management (TCM) framework by AACE is an integrated approach to Portfolio, Program and Project Management. TCM is a systematic approach to managing cost throughout the life cycle of any enterprise, program, facility, project, product or service. Comprises of;

• Strategic asset planning
• Project implementation
• Strategic asset performance measurement
• Strategic asset performance assessment
• Project control planning
• Project control plan implementation
• Project control measurement
• Project control performance assessment

What differentiates the TCM framework from other frameworks is its depth of coverage of the topics through Recommended Practices (RP) by the practitioners.

LEAN

Lean project management is the application of lean concepts such as lean construction, lean manufacturing and lean thinking to project management. The main principle of lean project management is delivering more value with less waste in a project context. Two well-known types are “Kanban” and “Last Planner System”.

Agile

Agile project management using SCRUM framework is the most popular framework within the Agile family of frameworks. SCRUM is a very simple framework for self-organizing teams to collaborate and deliver increments of the products in shorter iterations. Though agile project management (APM) have its roots in information technology domain there are many early adopters for it in EPC projects reporting positive results especially during early phases of engineering, execution and snagging.

The Best Practices Based Integrated Project Monitoring & Control

After detailed research of the above frameworks combined with our more than two decades of experience of working with projects, we defined the best practices-based project monitoring and control approach by picking up the best of the best practices cutting across project management frameworks.

Phase#1 Preparation

Focus – Get ready for the planning phase

• Scope definition (PMBOK, TCM, PRINCE2,Agile)
• Stakeholder identification (PMBOK)
• Role definition (PMBOK, TCM, PRINCE2, Agile)
• High level risk definition (PMBOK, TCM, PRINCE2)
• Information dissemination (PMBOK)

Phase#2 Planning

Focus – Plan in a way to facilitate almost real time project progress monitoring & controlling and forecasting

• Work Breakdown Structure definition (WBS) – (PMBOK, TCM, PRINCE2, Agile)
• Organization breakdown structure definition (OBS) – (PMBOK, PRINCE2, TCM, Agile)
• Establishing WBS-OBS linkages (PMBOK, TCM)
• Resource Breakdown Structure (RBS) – (PMBOK, TCM, Agile)
• Estimation & Budgeting (PMBOK, TCM, Agile)
• Cost breakdown structure (PMBOK, TCM)
• Schedule development (PMBOK, TCM, Agile)
• Rules of credit (TCM)
• Interfaces with other systems (Experience)
• Plan communications (PMBOK, TCM)
• Quality planning (PMBOK, TCM, PRINCE2)
• Risk planning (PMBOK, TCM, PRINCE2)
• Contingency planning (PMBOK, TCM)

Phase#3 Execution

Focus – Collect accurate and timely execution data. Control the dynamic incidents

• Project execution data capture (PMBOK, TCM, Agile, Experience)
• Change control (PMBOK, TCM, PRINCE2)
• Quality management (PMBOK, TCM)
• Risk control (PMBOK, TCM)
• Contingency management (TCM)
• Communication (PMBOK, TCM, Agile)

Phase#4 Monitoring & Controlling

Focus : Provide almost real time project status information to key stakeholders. Control quickly.

• Planned Value (PMBOK, TCM, Agile)
• Earned Value (PMBOK, TCM, Agile)
• Actual Cost (PMBOK, TCM)
• Variance analysis (PMBOK, TCM, Agile)
• Forecasting Schedule & Cost (PMBOK, TCM, Agile)
• Control schedule (PMBOK, TCM)
• Control costs (PMBOK, TCM)
• Forensic analysis (TCM)
• Control quality (PMBOK, TCM)
• Snag management (TCM, Experience)
• Risk monitoring (PMBOK, TCM)

Phase#5 Closing

Focus : Learning, Asset transition

• Formal closure (PMBOK, TCM)
• Asset transition (PMBOK, TCM)

Conclusion

The biggest problem project managers face across the globe are lack of project information on time for decision making. An integrated approach to project monitoring and controlling can solve this problem by providing almost real time project status information and the ability to forecast expected date and cost of completion.

Since every project management framework has their own strengths, it is advisable to cut across the various frameworks to choose the most appropriate best practices to support the integrated project monitoring and control function of your project.

References

The Project Management Body Of Knowledge by PMI, USA

TCM framework by AACE

Scrum Framework

Lean